Portfolio Management

Shelter in a Storm: Why Asset Allocation Matters Most in Volatile Markets

    • 2 min read
    • -29-Oct-2018
    • Share via

Markets move in cycles, and every few years a combination of macro and micro factors produces a stretch of volatility that tests investor conviction. In 2018, the broader market began correcting around February and March, while the Nifty held up on the strength of select heavyweights. The rupee then weakened from August onwards as US rates tightened and oil prices climbed.

When the Storm Hit

In September of that year, the perfect storm arrived. One of India's premier financial institutions defaulted on some of its debt obligations. The shock landed on an already fragile market at a time of the year when liquidity is typically tight, with advance tax payments and half-yearly closings drawing money out of the system. Events of this kind tend to push investors in one of two directions: impulsive action or paralysis that prevents any strategy from being executed at all.

Bull markets create an illusion of calm and stability that often leads investors to take on more risk than they can comfortably hold through a correction. A market like the one that followed September 2018 is, in many ways, the moment to revisit risk tolerance and reallocate, not to abandon the plan.

A long-term perspective and a measure of discipline are what keep investors committed to their objectives through periods of uncertainty. Equity delivers superior returns over the long run, but it is inherently volatile. The two cannot be separated. The question, then, is whether to react to short-term market movements or to prepare in advance for them.

Allocation Is Key

This is where asset allocation and an investment charter come into play. A prudent allocation across multiple asset classes reduces an investor's risk and makes returns more predictable and consistent over time.

Consider the data. Across the past 14 years, no single asset class has been a consistent winner from year to year, although equities have outperformed in the majority of years. However, an equally weighted portfolio across equity, debt, gold, and cash over the same period would have delivered an average return of around 11 per cent (see chart), comfortably above tax-free bonds. There was only one year in that period, 2008, in which the strategy produced a negative return, and even then, the loss was marginal. The 2008 result reflected the global financial crisis, during which most markets were battered.

The conclusion is straightforward: diversifying investments across asset classes reduces dependence on any single one and protects during periods of market turbulence. The right allocation for an individual investor depends on their risk appetite.

Risk Tolerance

Risk tolerance is shaped by several factors: investment horizon, liquidity needs, financial goals, and personal temperament. An investor with high risk tolerance may accept greater volatility in pursuit of higher returns and may allocate a larger share of the portfolio to higher-risk assets. An investor with lower risk tolerance will typically accept lower returns in exchange for a steadier, less volatile portfolio.

A portfolio combining equity and fixed income illustrates the trade-off. The equity component carries the potential for higher gains, while the fixed income component absorbs some of the associated risk. A portfolio that is well-diversified across asset classes can deliver superior risk-adjusted returns, which is the more meaningful measure for most long-term investors.

The Role of an Investment Charter

Asset allocation works only if it is held over time and across different market environments. This is where an investment charter strengthens the approach.

Investors today often take advice from multiple advisors, each of whom may have only a partial view of the overall portfolio. An investment charter sets out tailored rules for the portfolio, aligned to long-term goals. It increases the probability of reaching those goals by ensuring that the agreed allocation is followed across market cycles, not abandoned in response to short-term events.

Beyond keeping the portfolio aligned, an investment charter also helps mitigate portfolio-level risks, including the risk of impulsive decision-making. It sets out broad guidelines on asset class limits, manager selection, credit quality, and exposure to locked-in products, so that emotion is kept at arm's length when decisions are made.

The allocation set out in the charter should be reviewed periodically, and the portfolio rebalanced if it drifts beyond an agreed tolerance from the target. The four pillars of a well-constructed charter, covering investment objective, risk tolerance, investment horizon, and return expectations, have been addressed in detail in an earlier piece on the Investment Charter.

In Closing

A combination of a well-planned asset allocation and a custom investment charter is the practical way to plan for long-term financial goals. Asset allocation delivers superior risk-adjusted returns. The investment charter delivers the discipline required to stay the course when markets are turbulent. Together, they form the foundation that holds up when the storm arrives.

Our Blogs

View All Blogs